Many or all of the companies featured compensate us. Compensation and research may determine where and how companies appear. Learn more

Best Car Insurance of 2025

You are seeing personalized results sorted by which company wants your business the most -- because after over 200 hours of independent research we found that there's no one size-fits all. Read reviews, get quotes and save!
Last Updated: April 25, 2025
Top Car Insurance in Columbus, Ohio
Best Overall
Our Partner
  • Best for Reliable Claims Process
  • 24/7 customer service & strong network of local agents
  • Discounts for safe drivers and bundling
#2
Our Partner
  • Best for Competitive Rates
  • Discounts are available for over 850+ organizations & alumni associations
  • Obtain your quote online today - It's fast, easy & free!
#3
Our Partner
  • Best for Unique Coverage Options
  • Good financial ratings, cover specialty vehicles & 12 month rate guarantee
  • Customize your Coverage & Save -Only pay for what you need!
#4
Our Partner
  • Best for Comprehensive Coverage Options
  • Wide range of discounts, coverage options & add-ons
  • Safe Drivers Can Save Up To 40% Or More
#5
Our Partner
  • Best for Vanishing Deductible & Bundling Savings
  • SmartRide® Program Rewards Safe Drivers
  • Flexible Coverage Options for Every Driver
#6
Our Partner
  • Best for Military Members and Families
  • Special discounts for military members
  • Members saved an average of $725 annually when they switched to USAA Auto Insurance 
#7
Our Partner
  • Best for Roadside Assistance & Member Benefits
  • Exclusive Insurance Features for Loyal Members
  • Customizable Coverage with Optional Add-Ons
#8
Our Partner
  • Best for Customizable Policies 

  • Save 10% on Auto If You Bundle w/ Home.

  • 160+ Years in Business, 24/7 Claim Reporting.

#9
Our Partner
  • Best for Quick and Easy Coverage
  • Fast & straightforward application process - Get a Free and Quick Quote Online
  • A+ BBB Accredited Company
#10
Our Partner
  • Best for Personalized Service
  • Classic/specialty car coverage, roadside and towing assistance & optional Policy Perks available
  • Receive a quote online, file claims 24/7, and pays bills online or via the mobile app

Best Overall
Our Partner
  • Best for Reliable Claims Process
  • 24/7 customer service & strong network of local agents
  • Discounts for safe drivers and bundling