We research all brands listed and may earn a fee from our partners. Research and financial considerations may influence how brands are displayed. Not all brands are included. Learn more

Foremost Home Insurance Review

8 Customer Comments & Reviews - see all comments
Our content is free because we may earn a commission when you click or make a purchase using our site. Learn more.
Foremost is a Michigan insurance company that was founded in 1952 and was acquired by Farmers Insurance Group in 2000. It offers an array of consumer and business insurance products, including home, auto, mobile home, umbrella, and specialty vehicle coverage.

How is Foremost rated?

Breakdown

4.0/5
Coverage Options
3.5/5
Pricing and Discounts
4.0/5
Customer Service
3.5/5
Financial Strength
4.5/5
Add-On Coverages

Overall Rating: 3.8 / 5 (Very good)

As part of the much-larger Farmers Insurance Group, which in turn is part of the still-larger Zurich Group, Foremost has solid financial credentials. The company stands out for its willingness to cover nonstandard properties and to insure people whose policies have been cancelled or non-renewed by other companies. It maintains both an agent network and an interface, which allows customers to choose how to interact with the company. Pricing and discounts are in line with others in the industry, although policies that cover nonstandard homes and customers with credit issues and claims histories may be priced higher.

Financial Strength

Financial Strength - 3.5 / 5

Foremost has excellent ratings from Standard & Poor's and AM Best. Further, its backing by Farmers Insurance Group and its owner, Zurich Insurance Group, suggest impressive financial strength.
Underwriter
Farmers
Standard & Poor's Financial Rating
A
AM Best Financial Rating
A
*The above information reflects the financial strength of the underwriter of the Foremost home insurance policies: Farmers.

Customer Experience

Customer Service - 4 / 5

Since Foremost is owned by Farmers Insurance Group, but customers deal with Foremost employees, assessing the customer experience is difficult. Foremost has no BBB or TrustPilot ratings of its own. However, it does get favorable marks from the NAIC for its low complaint ratio. The company maintains an agent network, which benefits consumers who prefer a personal contact, but its online application and communication services are somewhat underdeveloped. Foremost partners with AARP on some insurance lines, which could be viewed as a vote of confidence in their customer experience.

National Association of Insurance Commissioners

NAIC Complaint Ratio
0.65
NAIC Total Complaints
55
*The NAIC complaint ratio (in this case 0.65) is a ratio of the number of complaints a company received to the total premiums written in a calendar year. The median complaint ratio across all companies is 1. A score below 1 means the company received fewer than average complaints. A score above 1 means the company received a higher number of complaints than average.

Foremost Coverage

Coverage Options - 4 / 5

Foremost offers homeowners coverage for people and houses that many other insurers avoid. The company emphasizes its willingness to write policies on nonstandard homes and older dwellings, and for people who have had credit problems or prior insurance cancellations or non renewals. Though these expanded coverages come at a price, the company's flexibility and history of insuring what other companies deem uninsurable is commendable.
Basic Coverage Types
Dwelling Protection
Other Structures Protection
Personal Property Protection
Liability Protection
Guest Medical Protection
Additional Coverage
Scheduled Personal Property Coverage

Pricing & Discounts

Pricing and Discounts - 3.5 / 5

The company's prices are in line with industry norms. Unsurprisingly, prices for coverage of nonstandard homes or for insuring people with past claims experience and poor credit history may be higher, but that too is in line with industry practice. Discounts are available to people over 50, people with no prior claims, and to holders of other Foremost policies.

Policy Discounts

  • Multi-Policy
  • Higher Deductible
  • Claim-Free

Contact & Additional Information

Homepage URL
Company Phone
(800) 527-3905
Headquarters Address
5600 Beech Tree Lane, Caledonia, MI, 49316
Mailing Address
P.O. Box 0915, Carol Stream, IL, 60132
Year Founded
1952

Leave a comment for Foremost Home Insurance
Minimum 12 words.
 No maximum length.
* What's Your Rating?
To make this comment as helpful as possible for our community, please provide at least 2 sentences.

8 Customer Comments & Reviews

Loading Reviews ...
Tony P
7/31/2023
Our house was hit by drunk driver. We had formost for some years. When it come time for repairs, company said we were only aloud used wood, yet we were paying high premiums. Had to go after drunk driver ourselves and was awarded over $8000 more but never was able to recover that. Judge said good luck with that. I was told by law professor that the judge or attorney should have been made to pay, but foremost did not help us recover loss from drunk driver. when you pay for insurance, I thought their suppose to help you with your claim. Not fight you for any coverage your entitled to.


J
Jeff
1/14/2023
We bought home insurance from foremost several years ago and in fact this same company has insured this mobile home now for well into 20 years. We just now had a first claim when a tree fell on our carport. we promptly reported it the same day we took and sent pictures to the agent assigned and we spoke to him and was told on Tuesday that he would have things settled by that Friday. Friday rolled around and i had to call him and was told he was working on it and would call me after lunch to discuss the settlement. but he didn't call so i called him back and he then told me he wouldn't be doing it until next Wednesday. In today's uncertain world when you tell a customer you will do... Read More


J
jim a
6/6/2022
Foremost property insurance sucks. ACV (actual cash value) is what you'll get after depreciation of your claim on your roof repairs. also, demolition on any property items or bldgs are extra and comes out of your pocket. I would advise anyone getting property insurance to go some where else. I did and all is much better now.


iowapreppers
5/11/2021
After the derecho storm in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, I contacted Foremost. They said my roof was 20 years old and everything was d err appreciated to zero. Since I had just recently purchased the home, I believed them until 3 different roofers told me the roof was a single layer new roof within a maximum of 1 to 4 years. Having read all the terrible things people have written, I can see why they only have 2.2 star rating.


agadgetman
1/7/2020
Don't Be Fooled By Empty Boasts and "Company Pledge" My grandfather passed away 5 years ago, and left the house to me. I've been paying Foremost since then, on time, and in the full amount. They just notified me we need to redo the policy in my name, and they would refund the annual payment "to the appropriate party". They wrote the check out to my deceased grandfather, who did not create an estate, and we have no way to cash the check. Foremost certainly has the ability to rewrite the check to my name (the person who owns the property, has a deed to the property, and has been paying insurance the last 5 years) -- isn't that by definition the appropriate party? They offer... Read More


Sharon R
1/3/2020
I have a comment alright maybe it can be answered. When I applied for my home owners insurance on November 03,2019 the very first thing I told the agent was I have a above ground swimming pool, is this going to be a problem? I was told no that Foremost is one of the only companies out there that does accept swimming pools. I also told her that I had no fence surrounding the pool, no problem I was told. I exclaimed that I have a deck with a locking gate, my ladder is a deck ladder not free standing at ground level. We installed the pool in June 2009 and replaced it once in the same spot. The pool is a above ground that has a five course retaining wall and the pool sits up off the ground it... Read More


derek
7/29/2019
Had 5 properties on a policy. Added a 6th with the tenant wanting to know if they could have an above ground pool. I contacted my agent and she contacted Foremost and was told it was OK. I then allowed the above ground pool in a 2 year lease. I then get a notice that the pool would have to be removed or they were cancelling my policy. My agent called back and went up the ladder and spoke to supervisors. She basically was told that "Small pools (up to 2 or 3 feet deep) were allowed" They are loosing all of my properties of which the agent found comparable coverage for much less money. When I called, I got an "I'm sorry". No stars from me if I could, but I had to give one to post.... Read More


Danny T
1/21/2019
Awful customer service. I had to cancel the policy and get a refund. Impossible to contact them via email or otherwise and they send a refund via Cheque via mail to the US ( while I live overseas ) Cheque payable to LLC could not ask anyone to cash the Cheque. It has cost me about 80 $ to post it overseas, when deposited it via the BoFa application it got charged back and the until now have to chase them for a 262$ refund already 100$ cost so far and waist of time. Anti customer CSR customer service very rigid attitude.



Top Rated

Wide Selection Of Home Insurance Discounts - Online Quotes In Minutes!

  • Covers common occurrences like fire or theft and accidents
  • Protect your valuable items (electronics and jewelry) 
  • A wide range of excellent coverage options